Home » $15,000 Classics: 1965 Ford Mustang vs 1984 Toyota 4×4 Pickup

$15,000 Classics: 1965 Ford Mustang vs 1984 Toyota 4×4 Pickup

Sbsd 11 8 2024
ADVERTISEMENT

Good morning! It’s Friday, when we do something out of the ordinary around here, and I just felt like this week’s choices didn’t lend themselves to a four-way shootout. So we’ll stick with the same-price theme, and just up the ante a little bit.

Yesterday I gave you two bad choices, and I had no idea which way you were going to go. As it turns out, most of you agreed with my thinking that the Pontiac has more potential, and represents a better value anyway because it runs and drives. I’m definitely in favor of the V8 swap ideas, but don’t forget to change that rear axle ratio, too; I’m sure it has at best a 2.73 gear set. A 700R4 overdrive transmission and some lower gears would make it a lot more pleasant.

Vidframe Min Top
Vidframe Min Bottom

I have nothing but respect for the Yugo, but I feel like you could probably find one that hasn’t been mothballed since before The Matrix had a sequel for a similar price. And I fear that if I ever got a Yugo, I’d always be disappointed that I didn’t hold out for a real Fiat 128, like I actually want.

Screenshot From 2024 11 07 16 59 50

Now then: It seems to me that the internet has been great for classic cars if you sell them, but maybe not so much if you’re hunting for bargains. You’re not likely to score that local treasure for a song when someone from a thousand miles away can find the same listing and outbid you. And since auction prices are generally public knowledge, asking prices for ordinary sales have gone up, too. It seems to me that neither of these cars would have cost this much a few years ago, but here we are. Which one is worth it these days? Let’s find out.

ADVERTISEMENT

1965 Ford Mustang – $15,000

00p0p 6mvsym0gnme 0ci0nf 1200x900

Engine/drivetrain: 200 cubic inch overhead valve inline 6, three-speed manual, RWD

Location: San Leandro, CA

Odometer reading: 26,000 miles (probably 126,000)

Operational status: Runs and drives great

ADVERTISEMENT

If you say the words “classic car” to a non-car person in America, chances are they’re going to picture either a ’57 Chevy, or a ’65 Mustang. You can find ten of these in just about any car show in the country. So what could possibly make it special enough to care about? Easy: Someone loves it. That’s all it takes. The seller bought this car from their uncle, did a shit-ton of work on it, and have been enjoying it. There are millions of others like it, as the saying goes, but this one is theirs, and it could be yours.

00q0q Fwp7d1ke6of 0t20ci 1200x900

It’s nothing special under the hood either, just an inline six and a three-speed manual. But it has a long list of new parts listed in the ad, and it runs like a top. The aluminum radiator is a nice touch, and the chrome dress-up kit is not something you see too often on a six-cylinder. It’s got all new fluids, new tires, a new battery, and lots more.

01010 Qjvsk4pipc 0ci0t2 1200x900

The interior is in nice shape as well, though the seller reports that the stock gauges don’t work except for the speedometer. They’ve added aftermarket gauges to cover oil pressure, coolant temperature, and fuel level – everything you need. The passenger’s seat upholstery also has a tear in it, but it’s not like Mustang restoration parts are hard to come by, if you wanted to fix it.

ADVERTISEMENT

01414 Cs5yggkgkyn 0ci0t2 1200x900

Also – and this is the big deal – it has been stripped to bare metal and repainted. No rust here. I have no idea if this is an original ’65 Mustang color, but I like it. It’s subtle. And, crucially, not “resale red.” The seller replaced all the weatherstripping after the repaint, too, so no worries about rain leaks.

1984 Toyota 4×4 Pickup – $15,000

01010 Gcnncnvnk1k 0ci0t2 1200x900

Engine/drivetrain: 2.4-liter overhead cam inline 4,  five-speed manual, part-time 4WD

Location: Rohnert Park, CA

ADVERTISEMENT

Odometer reading: 378,000 miles (!)

Operational status: Runs and drives great

If a classic Mustang doesn’t do it for you, how about an indestructible Toyota truck? If neither Jeremy Clarkson nor Marty McFly could kill one, there isn’t much chance of anyone else doing it. This one has lived a good long life, covering almost 400,000 miles in its forty years.

00e0e 954o6f8by5e 0ci0t2 1200x900

It’s not what you’d call stock anymore; it has at least a few inches of lift to clear 33-inch tires, a locking rear diff, and short off-road gearing. A tube bumper equipped with a winch show that someone meant business with this truck. It’s powered by a 22R four-cylinder and a five-speed stick, both rebuilt 20 years ago. It runs and drives great, according to the seller, and used to be a daily driver not long ago.

ADVERTISEMENT

00q0q Hrdsb30ocfs 0t20ci 1200x900

We don’t get any interior photos except this shot of the dash, showing the impressive number on the odometer. I presume the rest of the interior is in poor shape. It looks like some interior restoration parts are available, if you were so inclined.

01313 Hfhqa3mgdtp 0ci0t2 1200x900

The outside isn’t great either; it’s got dents, rust, and a Krylon and Rhino-Liner paint job. I imagine it was originally blue, but not this shade of blue. It’s a good-looking truck, but I’m not sure I’d call it “clean,” condition-wise.

Fifteen thousand dollars sounds like a lot for an old car, but based on these, it doesn’t seem to buy you much these days. One thing I can say for both of them is that they’ve clearly both been well-loved and well taken care of. One is clean and fresh, while the other still wears its battle scars. So what’ll it be – the shiny Mustang, or the beat-up truck?

ADVERTISEMENT

(Image credits: sellers)

Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on whatsapp
WhatsApp
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on linkedin
LinkedIn
Share on reddit
Reddit
Subscribe
Notify of
84 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Ramblin' Gamblin' Man
Ramblin' Gamblin' Man
1 month ago

Just call me “Mustang Sally” because there is no way that Toyota is worth 15K!

So, the Mustang wins by default.

Church
Church
1 month ago

I want to want the Toyota, but…

Canopysaurus
Canopysaurus
1 month ago

If both vehicles were stock and in excellent condition, I’d opt for the truck, but as they stand, neither vehicle is worth the asking price, especially the Toyota. Choosing the Mustang, not because I want it, but because I could probably turn around and sell it for what I paid for it.

CatMan
CatMan
1 month ago

Easiest decision I’ll have to make all day.

67Mustang
67Mustang
1 month ago

Ummm….No brainer on this one.

Ramblin' Gamblin' Man
Ramblin' Gamblin' Man
1 month ago
Reply to  67Mustang

^ User name checks out! 😉

FloridaNative
FloridaNative
1 month ago

Price seems high for a six cylinder gen1 Mustang, but it’s a veritable bargain compared to the POS Toyota.

Clark B
Clark B
1 month ago

I know Toyota trucks can command some high prices, but $15k for that one seems pretty steep. For that price I’d expect something in mostly original condition. Doesn’t have to be perfect, but this one has many dents and that spray on bedliner doesn’t inspire confidence. I’m almost certain the blue is a respray as well. Maybe it’s an original color and I’m wrong, but even in the pictures the paint has that flat, orange peel look I associate with quick repaints.

Alexk98
Alexk98
1 month ago

I’m not a mustang guy, and I tend to think that 1st gen Mustangs are wildly overvalued, but in this case, it’s not nearly as overpriced as that Toyota. Easy Mustang win

Jason Roth
Jason Roth
1 month ago

Easy choice. I really don’t like pickup trucks, so the Toyota isn’t my kind of vehicle.

Actually, I’m not super interested in Mustangs (I was raised on GMs, and it’s been decades since “cliche” became too weak a term for old guys with Mustangs), but I gotta say that the color on that thing is just fantastic.

I mean, in reality, if I had $15k to spend on a toy, it would almost certainly go to something British, or maybe the nicest Karmann Ghia on Earth, but if I were going to drive a Mustang, something pretty and not too muscle-y would be it.

Data
Data
1 month ago
Reply to  Jason Roth

Have you checked Ghia prices lately? $15,000 isn’t going to get you the nicest one. I regret having sold mine decades ago.

Jason Roth
Jason Roth
1 month ago
Reply to  Data

Oh man. I actually just checked BaT, and there was a nice convertible for $6k, albeit 3 days from closing.

ImissmyoldScout
ImissmyoldScout
1 month ago

I’m going for the Mustang, but hear me out on the engine swap. Drop in a 2.3 Ecoboost (300 HP) and a 6-speed Tremec, probably need to change the gearing in the rear end as well. Now you have a reliable, modern powertrain with decent fuel economy that makes more than enough power for what that car weighs.

The Stig's Misanthropic Cousin
The Stig's Misanthropic Cousin
1 month ago

Tough choice. I really like pickup trucks, so the Toyota is my kind of vehicle. I don’t know where the seller came up with the $15,000 price tag, though. If you look closely that truck is rough. I don’t expect perfection for $15,000, but I expect something better than a 30 footer. I’m also concerned that the owner isn’t even willing to show the interior; that is never a good sign. Plus, far nicer examples of these trucks have sold on BaT for around $15,000. That price tag is best described as “aspirational.”

Yesterday I expressed the opinion that I have no interest in seeing yet another ’65 Mustang or ’57 Chevy, and I stand by that. Both are cool cars, but I’ve seen too many of them. If I am being objective, though, the Mustang actually seems like a good deal. It is clearly the better purchase here, so it gets my vote.

Dogisbadob
Dogisbadob
1 month ago

I love Toyota, but in this case the Mustang is the better choice.

Michael Beranek
Michael Beranek
1 month ago

That’s a big ask for that Eurekamobile. I agree that the seller really doesn’t want to sell it.
Take the Mustang, pull the drive train and store it. Drop in a nice 347 stroker and a better transmission, and of course beef what it needs to deal with the power.
And if you sell it, you can include the original drive train.

67Mustang
67Mustang
1 month ago

“and of course beef what it needs to deal with the power.”

Everything. Brakes (including the single master cylinder), shocks, springs, rear axle, driveshaft, add power steering

or enjoy as-is

Michael Beranek
Michael Beranek
1 month ago
Reply to  67Mustang

All of that plus wheels and tires!

Drew
Drew
1 month ago

Somebody’s battered, probably questionably modified off-road Toyota or a nice, albeit basic, Mustang. Not to pile on, but this is one of the easiest showdowns yet.

Last edited 1 month ago by Drew
IRegertNothing, Esq.
IRegertNothing, Esq.
1 month ago

I’ll take the base model survivor Mustang. You can always swap in a 289 or so V8 later if you find the I6 underwhelming. Personally, I’d enjoy the car as it is and not fret over the lack of ‘Merica noises. The Toyota truck is way too hacked up and sloppy to be worth $15,000.

Racingtown
Racingtown
1 month ago

I have a truck and I don’t particularly think that one is worth 15k. The mustang would be a great Sunday driver. I’m going with that one today.

4jim
4jim
1 month ago

That truck is about the price those surviving solid axle toyota are going for in my area. I regret selling my 1982.

Musicman27
Musicman27
1 month ago

I think that truck still has a lot of life in it. I’d try to get a cheaper price but I might buy it.

XLEJim700
XLEJim700
1 month ago

That li’l pony car saw a lot of love.

I have room in my corral.

Vic Vinegar
Vic Vinegar
1 month ago

I know compact Toyota trucks go for stupid money, but this one is just particularly nuts to me. You can get newer, less used Tacomas that are still pretty darn “bulletproof” for $15k or not much more. This one looks beat to hell, and I’d guess there is rust still lurking, even if it looks like it has had extensive repairs. Dare I say, this is a $5k truck. A project to buy, maybe it is ready for trails today, but you have work to do to keep it long-term.

The Mustang looks legitimately nice. I’m sure everyone would rather it be a V8 car, but this thing will never not have a place to park at Cars and Coffee.

TheDrunkenWrench
TheDrunkenWrench
1 month ago

Are you KIDDING me? I can find Yotas cleaner than that, in that price range, up here in the land of salt and rust. That truck is a HOT MESS, and not the kind that’s fun to date for 6 months.

Mustang all day here.

ExAutoJourno
ExAutoJourno
1 month ago

Gotta be the ‘Stang.

You can get parts easily, and the six, while no fireball, can cruise. Besides, it’s rare, since so many of its kin have gotten 289 — or 302/351 — swaps.

Having had to put a later Taco to sleep after rust ate its frame, I have a definite bias against the Toyota. Which doesn’t have anything like the Mustang’s style, anyway.

Brandon Forbes
Brandon Forbes
1 month ago

That truck is priced as one of those that he doesn’t want to sell but the wife told him he has to so he’s listed it crazy high to make sure he gets to keep it

V10omous
V10omous
1 month ago

The pricing of old Toyotas has officially gone out of control.

You can get 2 or 3 times the truck elsewhere for this money. No dents or 400,000 miles required.

Angry Bob
Angry Bob
1 month ago
Reply to  V10omous

I had one like that in far better condition about a decade ago. Bought it for $3500 and sold it for $3500.

StillNotATony
StillNotATony
1 month ago

Mustang all the way. I get an itchy feeling that Toy is hiding rust under that rhino liner.

1 2 3
84
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x